Went to eat at Butter on Wednesday, hosted by my friend Wirt who cooks in Alex Guarnaschelli's kitchen. Because we all went with Wirt, we got extra TLC and a few bonus nibbles from the kitchen, so this is not going to be a review.
Disclaimer aside, if you're interested, here's what I have to say about it. People think of Butter first and foremost as a celeb hive. They don't discourage this reputation -- visit the a href="http://www.butterrestaurant.com/">Butter website and the first thing you see is a video of Paris Hilton on Letterman talking about how it's her favorite place to eat. An accolade like this might otherwise turn me against a place since:
1.) Where the celebs go, the lame wannabes follow
and
2.) I wouldn't ask a Mormon how to make a martini, so why should I take restaurant advice from someone who, clearly, doesn't eat?
But Wirt tells some great celeb stories, one of which is that Paris Hilton:
1.) Always brings flowers for the chef when she comes in.
2.) Couldn't be more gracious to the staff
and
3.) She eats. Yes, she really eats! And she tips really well.
And I believe him. It's plausible, don't you think? Yes, she courts attention, but that doesn't mean I should dismiss her as substance-less, right?
And so, here we are at Butter, a place with serious food that sometimes gets lost in the Page 6 shuffle. Alex Guarnaschelli is a true Greenmarket fanatic. I saw her there days after the birth of her daughter, Ava, chatting up her farmer friends and swooning over scallions. Butter's food reflects that passion -- a tower of onion rings is made from the Paffenroths' sweet Kelsae onions; panko-doused crispy oysters are nestled on a dill-fragrant tartar sauce and showered with edible purple flowers; sweet late summer fennel is roasted and transformed into a nourishing soup. I loved the cup of velvety watercress soup with its tiny truffled brie sandwich -- so dainty and pinky-in-the-air. My favorite entree was probably the slow-cooked pompano, enrobed in creamy beurre blanc atop a bed of Greenmarket sweet corn and greens -- light yet rich, it's the perfect transition dish between summer and fall.
And what a lovely room. Curved, lofty arches with woodgrain wallpaper are stacked horizontally against a lightbox image of a birch forest. Plush booths line the walls under low lights, punctuated by massive bunches of spindly, hunched branches. The room recesses endlessly -- it's like the Holland Tunnel under an enchantment spell by Galadriel. We were there on a Wednesday and the room wasn't loud -- in fact, all of the tables seemed to have that rare air of privacy that can be so hard to find in New York. It would be a great date restaurant.
Prices aren't insane (apps are about 16, entrees about 28), and portions are actually quite generous. I'm serious. And if you've got room at the end of the meal, get the raspberry beignets dipped in creme anglaise -- puffy little sugar-coated rounds with seedless raspberry coulis, they're what jelly doughnuts better be like in heaven. For your sake, I hope the dessert menu hasn't changed by the time you read this.
Butter
415 Lafayette St. at Astor
6 to Astor Pl.
(212) 253-2828
Recent Comments